Canadian Banks No Longer Leading US Banks. Trouble Ahead For The Canadian Economy?

The Canadian banks (XFN) have outperformed their US counterparts (XLF) since 2009.  They have been placed on a global pedestal due to their reluctance to participate in the subprime mortgage debt and collateralized debt obligations that precipitated the Great Recession.  Their balance sheets remained extremely healthy and their stock prices reflected this to this day.  But that was then...

Two of the 4 wheels have blown on the car that is the Canadian economy.  Precious metals and material stocks are down some 70% since 2011.  Now stocks of energy producing companies are free falling in tandem with the price of oil which seems to be in global abundance despite the fact that the opposite view held the public consensus only 6 years ago.  Don't get me started on the Canadian housing market.

Banks and financial sectors reflect the overall health of a country's economy.  Their relative performance is predictive of the relative performance of a given country's economy.  The chart above would suggest that growth in the US economy will continue to outpace that of the Canadian economy.  If the Canadian bank index is unable to post new 52-week highs and/or trends lower trouble is ahead.

Canadian vs. US Financials

The distance between key technical support and resistance levels post financial crisis is and should be more notable in the financial sector than any other sector. In March 2009, it really looked like the Financial Select Sector SPDR (XLF), which more or less tracks the US financial services sector, was going to zero. It bottomed at $5.73 in March 2009 and currently stands at $13.44. It is currently trading in a downward fashion toward support at ~$12-12.50. If this support level breaks significantly, there really is no other significant technical support in between it and the bottom.

The iShares CSN S&P TSX Capped Financials Index (XFN.TO), which more or less tracks the Canadian financial services sector, appears to be in much better shape than its US counterpart but has the same support gap problem. Support exists around ~$19-20, but below that who knows? One would have to look back to 2004 to see a small trading range where some support may exist around $17.

I think both of these charts are going to be restricted to large trading ranges for months. The XLF faces tremendous resistance at $20 and will only break through it when a strong recovery is underway.